---
title: "My Password Works on philosophersnotes.com and legacy.heroic.us but Not heroic.us, Do I Need Different Logins for Each?"
description: "Yes, and here's why, plus how to find the right one for each platform."
url: https://help.heroic.us/en/articles/8-my-password-works-on-philosophersnotescom-and-legacyheroicus-but-not-heroicus-do-i-need-different-logins-for-each
collection: "Login and Access"
updated: 2026-08-28
language: en
---

# My Password Works on philosophersnotes.com and legacy.heroic.us but Not heroic.us, Do I Need Different Logins for Each?

Yes, and here's why, plus how to find the right one for each platform.

## Why this happens

If you signed up before August 2025, your original account lives on our legacy platform, [legacy.heroic.us](https://legacy.heroic.us). Philosopher's Notes has its own platform too, with a separate legacy login for members who signed up before August 2025 at [app.philosophersnotes.com](https://app.philosophersnotes.com/). Meanwhile, [heroic.us](https://heroic.us) is our current platform, built as its own account system. So it's normal for your legacy credentials to work fine on [legacy.heroic.us](https://legacy.heroic.us) and app.philosophersnotes.com/legacy, while [heroic.us](https://heroic.us) doesn't recognize them at all.

## **Do you need a new** [**heroic.us**](https://heroic.us) **account?**

Not necessarily; it depends on whether you've purchased anything through [heroic.us](https://heroic.us) directly. If you have, use the email and password you set up there specifically, that's a separate login from your legacy one. If you haven't purchased anything through [heroic.us](https://heroic.us) and don't need to right now, you likely don't need a [heroic.us](https://heroic.us) login at all, your legacy and PN access already covers what you're paying for.

## If you're not sure which platform has what you need

Message us with what you're trying to access (Heroic Live content, Philosopher's Notes, a specific course) and roughly when you signed up. We'll point you to the right platform.

## Password reset tip

If you try resetting your password anywhere, use the "Forgot Password" link on that specific platform's login page rather than resetting through a different one, since the platforms don't share reset flows either.
